Spartacus

Sources and historiography

Historical accounts of Spartacus and the Third Servile War rely on a limited number of ancient Greek and Roman texts, none of which were authored by eyewitnesses, participants, or enslaved people.^[1] The earliest surviving narratives date from at least a generation after the conflict.^[1] The most proximate contemporary historian was Gaius Sallustius Crispus (Sallust), writing in the 40s BC, who had access to living participants in the events, though his Histories survive only in scattered fragments.^[2][3][4] The detailed books of Titus Livius (Livy) covering the period in his History of Rome from Its Foundation are lost, surviving only in brief chapter summaries known as periochae.^[3][4]

The two principal continuous narratives were written more than a century after Spartacus died: the Life of Crassus by Plutarch of Chaeronea (c. 46–119 AD) and the Civil Wars by Appian of Alexandria (c. 95–165 AD).^[4][5] Both authors reconstructed events from earlier lost records, displaying distinct perspectives and biases.^[3][5] Lucius Annaeus Florus composed an epitome of Roman history in the second century AD, providing a hostile perspective drawn from Sallust and Livy.^[3][4][6] Additional details and anecdotes appear in works by Gaius Velleius Paterculus, Sextus Julius Frontinus, Flavius Eutropius, and Paulus Orosius.^[3][4] These secondary texts regularly present the revolt unfavorably, yet they preserve contradictory traditions concerning rebel motivations, troop numbers, and command structures.^[3][7]

The precise chronology of the outbreak of the war has generated debate among historians.^[8] Ancient writers offer conflicting synchronisms: Eutropius dates the outbreak to the year 678 from the foundation of Rome (76 BC) and mentions the assignment of Macedonia to proconsul Marcus Licinius Lucullus, whereas Orosius dates it to 679 AUC (75 BC) under the consulship of Lucullus and Cassius.^[9][10][11] In 1872, the German scholar Otfried Schambach argued that the uprising began in 74 BC, concluding that Eutropius confused Marcus Lucullus with his brother Lucius, who was consul in 74 BC.^[12] Alexander Mishulin likewise supported 74 BC, arguing that Crassus took command in the third year of the revolt and campaigned for about five months.^[13]

In 1957, the scholar A. Motus re-evaluated the textual evidence, pointing out translation errors in Mishulin's reading of Eutropius and noting that Appian counted yearly intervals by consular elections held in summer.^[8] Motus argued that the rapid assembly of rebel numbers and the mention of the proconsul Licinius Lucullus point to an outbreak in 73 BC.^[8] Modern historical consensus places the escape from Capua in 73 BC, with suggestions for the season ranging from late winter to spring or early summer.^{[14][15][16][17][18][19]}

Origins and early life

All surviving classical sources describe Spartacus as a Thracian by birth.^{[6][20][21][22][23][24]} Plutarch characterizes him as a Thracian of nomad stock (nomadikon).^[21][25] In 1955, the German philologist Konrat Ziegler proposed that the manuscript reading nomadikon was an error introduced by a medieval copyist for Maidikon, referring to the Maedi tribe.^[26] This emendation has been widely accepted by modern historians.^[27][28][29] The Maedi inhabited the southwestern fringe of Thrace along the middle course of the Strymon River (the modern Struma in southwestern Bulgaria), along the border with the Roman province of Macedonia.^[26][30] Alternative tribal affiliations, such as the Bessi of the Rhodope Mountains or the Getae along the Danube, have also been discussed based on local naming patterns.^[31][32][33]

Etymological and onomastic analyses link the name Spartacus (Greek: Spartakos or Spardakos) to Thracian roots meaning famous for his spear, localized in western Thrace.^[34][35] Parallels exist across the Black Sea region, where five rulers of the Spartocid dynasty of the Cimmerian Bosporus and Pontus bore the name.^[36][37][38] A Thracian named Sparadokos, father of King Seuthes I of the Odrysian kingdom, is also documented in classical records.^[39] Based on these royal and aristocratic naming parallels, 19th-century historian Theodor Mommsen and later scholars suggested that Spartacus may have come from a noble or princely lineage.^[38][40][41] Plutarch's remark that he was superior in understanding and gentleness of character, appearing more like a Greek than a barbarian, has been cited to support an educated, high-status upbringing.^[21][42]

Classical authors provide differing explanations for how Spartacus fell into servitude. Appian states that he fought against the Romans, was taken prisoner, and was sold into slavery.^[20][43] Florus provides a different progression, asserting that he was a Thracian tributary mercenary who became a Roman soldier, deserted, became a bandit, and was made a gladiator on account of his physical strength.^[6][44] Scholars accepting Appian's account suggest that he may have been captured during Roman campaigns in Thrace, such as the expedition of Lucius Cornelius Sulla against the Maedi in 85 BC, operations at the start of the Second Mithridatic War in 83 BC, or the victory of proconsul Appius Claudius Pulcher in 76 BC.^[45][46][47]

Theodor Mommsen endorsed Florus's summary of mercenary service and desertion.^[48] The Italian historian Emilio Gabba hypothesized that Spartacus served in auxiliary cavalry units under Sulla when the proconsul landed in Italy in 83 BC during the civil war against the Marian faction.^[49] Thracians were widely recruited as cavalrymen, and Spartacus fought mounted in his final battle.^[50][51] If he deserted from Sulla's forces, he may have joined the Marian party in guerrilla actions across Italy, acquiring familiarity with the peninsula's topography and Roman military doctrine.^[50][52] Tacitus later drew an explicit parallel between Spartacus and Tacfarinas, characterizing both as deserters and bandits.^[53]

Ancient texts record that Spartacus was sold as a slave at least three times, with the first sale taking place in Rome.^[21] Diodorus Siculus mentions an individual from whom Spartacus received a benefaction, possibly an initial owner who granted him privileged treatment.^[54][55] He was later sold without fault, according to Marcus Terentius Varro, to a master who treated him harshly and transferred him to a gladiatorial establishment.^[56] Roman masters retained the legal right to condemn slaves to the arena without giving cause.^[57] Florus emphasizes that his physical size and strength prompted his assignment to gladiatorial combat.^[6]

Plutarch writes that Spartacus's wife was enslaved alongside him.^[30] She was a Thracian woman of the same tribe, described as a prophetess devoted to the Dionysian mysteries.^[21][30][58] According to Plutarch, she once saw a serpent coiled around the face of Spartacus while he slept and proclaimed it an omen of great and formidable power that would lead him to an unfortunate end.^[21][59] This prophetic incident was remembered among his companions and enhanced his prestige within the training school.^[60] The fact that his wife lived with him in Capua indicates that he enjoyed privileged quarters within the barracks, rather than standard confinement.^[60]

Gladiatorial training in Capua

Spartacus was purchased by the lanista Gnaeus Cornelius Lentulus Batiatus, who operated a gladiatorial training school (ludus) in Capua in the fertile region of Campania.^[60][61][62] The establishment housed a substantial population of combatants, consisting predominantly of enslaved Gauls, Germans, and Thracians.^[59][63] Modern estimates by Vladimir Goroncharovsky suggest Spartacus was approximately thirty years old when he entered the school, placing his birth around 103 BC.^[64][65] Other researchers propose he may have entered in his early twenties, given that gladiators rarely continued fighting past thirty without gaining retirement.^[66]

Sources disagree on Spartacus's fighting classification. The English and Russian texts describe him as a murmillo, a heavyweight combatant equipped with a large oblong rectangular shield (scutum), a short straight thrusting sword (gladius) about 18 inches long, an arm guard (manica) on the right forearm, and a helmet.^[61][64] Florus similarly identifies him as a murmillo.^[67] Other historians argue he was trained as a Thraex, using a small round or square shield (parma) and a curved sword (sica), which matched his ethnic origin, noting that murmillo designations might reflect confusion by later Roman chroniclers.^[67][68] Classical texts preserve no details of his public arena matches in Capua prior to the revolt.^[62]

Outbreak of the rebellion (73 BC)

In 73 BC, gladiators at Batiatus's school hatched a conspiracy to break out of captivity.^[25][69] Synesius of Cyrene recorded that the immediate trigger was an impending public spectacle in which the gladiators were destined to serve as expiatory sacrifices for the Roman populace.^[69] Around two hundred gladiators took part in the plot, or 300 by another account..^[63][69][70] Batiatus learned of the planned escape through an informer and took defensive measures.^[63][69] Alerted to the betrayal, a small group preempted the guards, seized kitchen implements such as spits, choppers, and carving knives from the cookhouse, and forced their way out of the building.^[25][69]

Ancient authorities report divergent numbers for those who successfully broke through the gates. Plutarch numbers the fugitives at 78; Livy, Frontinus, and Eutropius report 74; Appian states about 70; Orosius gives 64.; Cicero mentions fewer than 50; and Florus estimates about 30.^{[10][20][21][71][72][73][74][75][76]} Outside the school, the fugitives intercepted several wagons transporting gladiatorial armor and weapons destined for another arena, seizing the contents to equip themselves.^[25][63] They beat off a local garrison squad dispatched from Capua to recapture them, stripped the fallen Roman militia of authentic military equipment, and discarded their gladiatorial gear.^[25][77]

The escaped fighters chose three principal commanders: Spartacus and two Gallic slaves, Crixus and Oenomaus.^[78][79] Appian notes that Spartacus instituted an equal division of captured spoils among all members of the company, establishing disciplined communal cohesion.^[20][78] Sallust indicates that Spartacus was recognized from the outset as the chief leader of the gladiators, with Crixus and Oenomaus serving as his primary lieutenants.^[73][80][81] Seeking a secure base, the band marched southward through Campania and established an encampment inside the caldera of Mount Vesuvius, which was dormant and heavily overgrown with wild brush and vines.^[25][43]

Early campaigns and Vesuvius

The Romans considered the uprising more of a policing matter than a war, and their response was hampered by the absence of the legions, which were fighting a revolt in Hispania and the Third Mithridatic War..^[82][83][84] A hastily conscripted militia of roughly 3,000 men was assembled under the command of praetor Gaius Claudius Glaber (identified in various sources as Clodius, Claudius Pulcher, or Varinius Glaber).^{[11][20][74][82][85][86]} Glaber marched to Vesuvius and blockaded the single narrow, steep trail leading to the summit, intending to starve the rebels into unconditional surrender.^[82][84][87]

Spartacus bypassed the blockade through an unorthodox tactical maneuver. His men harvested wild grapevine tendrils growing along the volcanic slopes, wove them into sturdy climbing ladders, and descended the sheer, unmonitored rock cliffs at the rear of the mountain during the night.^[82][87][88] Florus describes them descending through the hollow fissure of the mountain.^[86] Circumnavigating the volcano, they launched a surprise rear assault on Glaber's unfortified camp while the Roman sentries and recruits were unprepared, killing most of the militia and forcing the survivors to flee in panic.^[82][87] Frontinus records that several cohorts were routed by the initial band of gladiators.^[75]

Following the victory at Vesuvius, thousands of rural slaves, runaway farmhands, day laborers, and regional herdsmen flooded into the rebel camp.^[85][89][90] The herdsmen and shepherds of Campania, Samnium, and Lucania were hardy and agile outdoorsmen, many of whom brought riding horses and livestock stolen from their masters.^[85][89][91] Historians note that the region had suffered heavy devastation nine years earlier during the Social War (91–87 BC) and Sulla's punitive campaigns against the Samnites, leaving a disenfranchised local population hostile to the Senate.^[91][92] Spartacus incorporated these recruits into an organized force, probably forming units modeled on Roman infantry cohorts and legions, accompanied by newly established cavalry squadrons.^[91][92][93]

To address severe weapons shortages, the insurgents engaged in extensive improvisation.^[94] Sallust records that rebel fighters hardened pointed wooden spears in open fires, producing weapons capable of inflicting injuries comparable to iron.^[95] Frontinus adds that they manufactured wicker shields covered in animal hides stripped from slaughtered farm stock.^[96][97] They broke into rural slave prisons (ergastula), liberating captive field hands and melting down the iron chains and fetters to forge broadswords and projectile points.^[97]

Campaigns against Varinius

Alarmed by Glaber's destruction, the Roman Senate dispatched praetor Publius Varinius with two legions raised from raw recruits.^[20][83][98] Varinius carelessly divided his forces, and Spartacus began to defeat them one part at a time..^[95] Spartacus first ambushed a 3,000-man detachment commanded by legate Furius.^[99] Next, he launched a sudden strike against the camp of legate Cossinius near Salinae, between Herculaneum and Pompeii; Cossinius was bathing when the attack began, narrowly escaped capture, but was pursued and killed alongside numerous legionaries.^[99]

Varinius's remaining 4,000 soldiers suffered from winter cold, sickness, and low morale, leading to widespread desertion.^[99] After receiving reinforcements, Varinius managed to trap the rebel camp. Facing food shortages, Spartacus executed a stealthy nighttime evacuation, leaving campfires burning and propped-up corpses holding weapons along the palisades to simulate active sentries.^[99] When the praetor resumed offensive operations, internal dissension surfaced in the rebel camp; Sallust notes that Crixus and his Gallic and Germanic followers pressed for an immediate offensive, while Spartacus advised caution.^[95] The subsequent engagement ended in a rout of Varinius, who lost his horse, lictores, and fasces to the insurgents.^[99][100] Florus records that Spartacus assumed the captured consular symbols of authority.^[99]

The rebels then routed another force under Gaius Thoranius, the quaestor of Varinius, consolidating control over rural southern Italy.^[101] The slave army overran and looted the Campanian towns of Nola and Nuceria, and advanced across Lucania to storm Thurii, Consentia, and Metapontum.^[101][102] Sallust records that despite Spartacus's explicit orders, bands of insurgents engaged in widespread looting, arson, murder, and the rape of free women.^[103][104] To counter these outrages, Spartacus intervened where possible; Orosius records that after a noble matron committed suicide following a sexual assault, Spartacus arranged a public funeral with military honors, forcing 400 captured Romans to fight in gladiatorial combat around her pyre.^[105][106]

The insurgents spent the winter of 73–72 BC on the plains near Metapontum, manufacturing armaments, training fresh recruits, and gathering provisions.^[101][102] By this stage, the rebel assembly numbered between 40,000 and 70,000 people.^{[20][89][107]} Orosius estimates that 10,000 fighters followed Crixus, while Spartacus commanded 30,000.^[107] Appian reports 70,000 total insurgents, reflecting the steady arrival of rural laborers, shepherds, and escaped slaves from southern latifundia.^[20][89] Spartacus strictly regulated commercial trade in his camps, prohibiting the personal possession or circulation of gold and silver while exchanging captured bronze, iron, and cattle with merchants solely for weapons-grade metals.

Consular campaigns of 72 BC

In the spring of 72 BC, the Roman Senate dispatched both sitting consuls, Lucius Gellius Publicola and Gnaeus Cornelius Lentulus Clodianus, to crush the uprising with four full consular legions and allied contingents, totaling at least 30,000 soldiers.^{[43][93][108]} Among the young nobles serving under the consuls was Marcus Porcius Cato, later known as Cato of Utica.^[109] Historians suppose that the consuls acted together and aimed to attack Spartacus from two sides near the Gargano peninsula, with Gellius advancing through Campania and Apulia and Lentulus marching directly across the Apennines along the Via Tiburtina..

At this juncture, the rebel forces fractured. A division of 20,000 (according to Livy) or 30,000 men (according to Appian), composed primarily of Gauls and Germans under Crixus, separated from Spartacus's main army and operated independently near Mount Garganus in northern Apulia.^{[110][111][112]} Ancient sources and modern historians debate the motives for this split, suggesting either strategic disagreements over whether to exit Italy or an intentional screening operation by Crixus to secure Spartacus's flank.^{[113][114][115]} Consular forces under Gellius and his propraetor Quintus Arrius surprised Crixus's contingent near Mount Garganus, annihilating two-thirds of the rebel force and killing Crixus on the field.^{[110][116][117]}

Spartacus maneuvered rapidly to prevent the consuls from uniting their armies.^[113][116] Intercepting Lentulus Clodianus during his march through the Apennine passes, Spartacus attacked the consular legions, defeated them, and captured their baggage train.^{[110][116][118]} Turning immediately against Gellius Publicola's advancing forces, Spartacus defeated the second consular army in a pitched battle.^{[110][116][118]} To commemorate the death of Crixus, Spartacus selected 300 captured Roman legionaries and forced them to fight one another to the death in gladiatorial combat around the funeral pyre.^[116][119] Smith and modern historians note that this funeral ritual mirrored aristocratic Roman games, turning Roman institutions against Roman captives.^[116][120]

Following his victories over the consuls, Spartacus marched north along the Adriatic coast toward Cisalpine Gaul..^{[85][118][121]} Near Mutina (modern Modena), the governor of Cisalpine Gaul, proconsul Gaius Cassius Longinus, and praetor Gnaeus Manlius barred the route with an army of 10,000 legionaries.^[118][121] Spartacus attacked the Roman forces, crushed their lines, and forced Cassius to flee for his life.^{[85][118][121]} Orosius reports that Longinus was killed during the route, though other sources indicate he escaped.^[121][122] With this victory, the rebel army reached the Padus (Po) River, placing them at the threshold of the Alpine mountain passes.^[118][121]

Reversal to the south and strategic intentions

At the Po River, with the road out of Italy open, Spartacus reversed his march and led his followers back toward the south.^{[123][124][125]} Classical and modern historians offer competing explanations for this unexpected turn.^[123] Plutarch asserts that Spartacus's original aim was to cross the Alps and disperse the liberated slaves back to their homelands in Gaul and Thrace, but that his followers, intoxicated by successive victories and eager for plunder, refused to leave Italy.^{[123][124][125]} Appian and Florus claim that Spartacus conceived an ambition to march directly on the city of Rome itself.^[110]

Modern historiography has proposed alternative hypotheses. Some scholars suggest that the rebel rank and file included large numbers of non-combatant women, children, and elderly people who feared a crossing of the snowbound Alpine passes in winter.^[123][124] Others point out that a substantial portion of the army consisted of freeborn Italian rural laborers and herdsmen who sought to overthrow Roman dominance within Italy rather than emigrate abroad.^[123][126] A further hypothesis suggests that Spartacus marched north to join forces with Quintus Sertorius, but learned of Sertorius's death after the battle at Mutina.^[127] Some historians argue that a portion of the army, estimated at up to 10,000 non-combatants, did cross the Alps and return to their European homelands.^[124]

During their stay in the Po Valley, the rebel army grew substantially as local rural laborers and disenfranchised Transpadane Gauls joined the ranks.^[128] Eutropius estimates the army at 60,000 fighters, while Appian reports that it expanded to 120,000 men.^{[10][89][112]} In the autumn of 72 BC, Spartacus began his southward march along the Adriatic coast.^[128] To maximize speed, he ordered all Roman prisoners executed, excess pack animals slaughtered, and surplus baggage wagons burned.^[129][130] Orosius notes that terror gripped Rome comparable to the panic during the Second Punic War when Hannibal Barca stood before the city walls.^[131] The consuls attempted to block the rebel advance in Picenum, but Spartacus routed their combined legions once again.^[129][130]

Command of Marcus Licinius Crassus

Faced with the failure of both consular armies, the Roman Senate stripped Gellius and Lentulus of their commands before November 72 BC.^[126][132] Extraordinary proconsular imperium was assigned to Marcus Licinius Crassus, the wealthiest patrician in Rome and the sole volunteer for the assignment.^[132][133] Crassus mobilized an army consisting of six newly raised legions financed largely from his private fortune, alongside the four demoralized consular legions, giving him a total force of 40,000 to 60,000 trained legionaries.^{[133][134][135]}

To restore military discipline among the defeated consular troops, Crassus revived the ancient and rarely used punishment of decimation (decimatio).^[133][136] The soldiers who had fled in battle were segregated into groups of ten, with one man chosen by lot from each group to be clubbed or beaten to death (verberatio) by his fellow legionaries.^[136] The measure was intended to make the Roman soldiers more afraid of their commander than of their rebel enemies.^[133]

Crassus intercepted the rebel army on the southern border of Picenum.^[137] He deployed six legions along the operational front and detached his legate Mummius with two legions to maneuver into a rear blocking position, issuing strict orders not to engage in combat.^[137][138] Mummius disobeyed orders, attacked Spartacus at what appeared to be an advantageous moment, and suffered a rout with heavy casualties and the loss of legionary equipment.^[137][138] Crassus then defeated Spartacus in several battles and pushed him farther south.^[139] In another account, Crassus retrained his troops after Mummius's defeat and left Spartacus alone for a time..^[137] Under persistent pressure, Spartacus withdrew through Lucania into the southern tip of Bruttium, encamping in late 71 BC at Rhegium (modern Reggio Calabria) on the Strait of Messina.^{[122][138][140]}

Bruttium campaign and the isthmus siege

Encamped on the coast of Bruttium, Spartacus planned to ferry his army across the Strait of Messina into Sicily.^{[88][138][140]} Sicily held a dense enslaved population and had been the center of two major slave revolts in the preceding half-century (135–132 BC and 104–101 BC).^[88][141] Plutarch noted that only a spark was needed to reignite rebellion across the island.^[141] Lacking a fleet, Spartacus made an agreement with Cilician pirates to carry him and about 2,000 of his men to Sicily, where he intended to incite a slave revolt.^[138][140] At its narrowest the strait is 3.1 kilometers wide..^[142] The Cilician pirates accepted payment but sailed away without fulfilling the agreement.^{[88][138][140]} Historians hypothesize that bad weather prevented the voyage, that Pontic diplomacy intervened, or that the propraetor of Sicily, Gaius Licinius Verres, bribed the pirate captains.^[88][143]

The insurgents attempted to cross the strait by building rafts from timber and sealed barrels, but winter squalls and swift currents in the strait destroyed the improvised vessels.^{[142][144][145]} Cicero later noted that Crassus organized naval patrols to ensure no crossing could take place.^[146] Recognizing that the rebels were confined to the peninsula, Crassus ordered the construction of a continuous defensive fortification across the narrowest point of the Isthmus of Catanzaro, sealing the rebels off from the rest of Italy.^[142][147] Accounts give the length of the fortification from the Tyrrhenian Sea to the Ionian Sea as 30, 55 or about 65 kilometers.^{[142][148][149]} It consisted of a trench 4.5 meters deep, which one account also gives as 4.5 meters wide, backed by an earthen rampart with a wall or palisade..^[142][148]

Trapped in a small area, the rebel forces soon began to suffer from a lack of food..^[149][150] Direct daytime assaults on the Roman wall were repelled with heavy casualties; Appian claims that 6,000 rebels fell in an early morning assault and another 6,000 in an evening attack, though modern historians consider these figures inflated.^[151] Spartacus adjusted his tactics to continuous guerrilla harassment.^[150] He crucified a prisoner in no-man's-land between the lines; according to Appian, this was so that his own men could see the fate awaiting them if they were defeated, while another account presents it as an attempt to provoke the Romans into a pitched battle.^[150][152] During late winter, amid a blinding snowstorm, Spartacus mobilized his vanguard, filled a narrow section of the Roman trench with earth, timber, and corpses, and broke through Crassus's lines into open territory.^[153]

Breakout and preliminary clashes

After breaking the siege lines, Spartacus led his army toward Brundisium (modern Brindisi) on the Adriatic coast, intending to seize transport ships and cross the sea to Epirus or Thrace.^{[145][153][154]} However, the Roman Senate had recalled proconsul Gnaeus Pompeius Magnus from Hispania and proconsul Marcus Terentius Varro Lucullus from Macedonia.^[155][156] Appian records that Lucullus's veteran legions landed at Brundisium, blocking the rebel line of retreat.^{[153][154][157]} Hearing of Pompey's involvement, Spartacus tried to make a truce with Crassus, but Crassus refused..^[150][157]

Disagreements over strategy again divided the rebel command.^[158] A faction of 35,000 Gauls and Germans (according to Livy) or 12,000 men (according to Plutarch), commanded by Gannicus and Castus, separated from Spartacus's main force and encamped by the Lucanian Lake.^[158][159] Crassus attacked the dissident camp, but Spartacus arrived with his main army and forced the Roman legions to withdraw.^[158][160] Crassus then set a trap: feigning an engagement against Spartacus, he sent twelve cohorts under Pomponius and Quintus Marcius Rufus around a neighboring mountain to take Gannicus and Castus from the rear.^[161] Plutarch called the resulting engagement the bloodiest battle of the whole war.^[158] The rebels were wiped out almost to a man, and only two of the dead slaves had fatal wounds in the back..^{[124][158][162]}

Spartacus withdrew into the Petelian Mountains (near modern Strongoli in Calabria), shadowed by Roman pursuing columns commanded by legate Quintus Arrius and quaestor Gnaeus Tremellius Scrofa.^[158] Turning abruptly on his pursuers, Spartacus ambushed the Roman vanguard, routed the cohorts, and severely wounded Scrofa.^[158][162] This tactical success proved disastrous for the rebels, as the rank-and-file fighters became overconfident and refused to continue their orderly retreat toward the coast.^{[158][163][164]} Surrounding their officers with drawn weapons, the soldiers forced Spartacus to turn the entire army around and advance through Lucania to face Crassus in open battle.^{[158][163][164]}

Final battle and death (71 BC)

The decisive engagement of the war took place in April 71 BC in the high valley of the Sele River (the Silarus), on the boundary between Campania and Lucania (in the modern territory of Senerchia, between Oliveto Citra and Calabritto near Quaglietta).^{[148][157][165]} According to Plutarch, Crassus was eager to conclude the campaign before Pompey arrived from the north, expecting that the credit for the victory would otherwise go to Pompey.^[155][158] Velleius Paterculus reports that Spartacus commanded roughly 49,000 men, while other classical estimates suggest 35,000 to 40,000 combatants.^[89][166] As Crassus's troops began digging an entrenched camp near the river, rebel detachments engaged the Roman diggers, escalating into a general battle across the plain.^[167]

Plutarch recounts that prior to the clash, when an attendant brought Spartacus his warhorse, he drew his sword and killed the animal in full view of his army.^[148][158] He declared that if he won the battle, he would have many fine horses from the enemy, and if he lost, he would have no need of one.^[148][158] Modern historians suggest this act may have been an ancient Thracian pre-battle sacrifice, misconstrued by Greek authors.^[165] Spartacus formed his infantry in deep ranks and led an elite cavalry strike force aimed directly at Crassus's command post.^[165]

In the melee, rebel infantry buckled under the weight of the disciplined legionary cohorts.^[165] Spartacus cut his way toward Crassus, killing two centurions who stood in his path.^[148][158] Appian describes his final moments: struck in the thigh by a throwing spear (javelin), Spartacus dropped to one knee, raised his shield before him, and fought off encircling Roman soldiers until he was overwhelmed and cut down.^[153][168] His body was never recovered or identified from among the thousands of corpses littering the battlefield.^{[148][153][157]}

Archaeological discoveries in the upper Sele Valley since 1899 have unearthed Roman-era swords, armor, and helmets consistent with a massive military engagement. In 1927, a fragment of a fresco was found in Pompeii on a wall of the house of the priest Amandus, which was built around 70 BC.^[169] The surviving plaster displays two battle scenes: a mounted warrior labeled Felix of Pompeii driving a lance into the thigh of an opposing horseman inscribed Spartaks, alongside fallen foot soldiers wounded in the legs.^[169] Scholars consider this fresco the earliest visual representation of the final battle.^[169]

Aftermath and suppression

According to the Livian epitome, over 60,000 rebels were killed in the Battle of the Silarus, while the Roman army lost approximately 1,000 legionaries.^{[148][170][171]} Surviving rebels scattered into the neighboring mountains, where Crassus's legions hunted them down.^[158] Six thousand captured insurgents were crucified along the Appian Way between Capua and Rome, a distance of more than 100 miles.^[157][158] Under Roman legal practice, their bodies were left unburied to decompose on the crosses for years as a public warning.^[124][158] Crassus later freed 3,000 prisoners whom the rebels had taken..^[158][165]

A remnant of 5,000 rebels escaped northward through Etruria, attempting to reach the Alps.^[124][158] On their way north they met the legions of Pompey, which had returned from Hispania, and were wiped out..^[172] Pompey wrote to the Senate claiming primary credit for ending the rebellion, stating that while Crassus had defeated the fugitives in battle, he had extirpated the war by its roots.^[158] Pompey was granted a full triumph for his victories in Hispania, whereas Crassus received an ovation, though the Senate permitted Crassus to wear a laurel wreath instead of the customary myrtle.^[173][174] Isolated guerrilla bands continued to operate in southern Italy for years; Cicero recorded fighting in Bruttium in 70 BC, and in 62 BC Gaius Octavius (father of Augustus) suppressed rebel remnants holding the town of Thurii.^[175][176]

Social and economic consequences

The Third Servile War caused significant devastation across the agricultural heartland of southern Italy, with numerous estates and towns plundered.^[177] Historians identify the war as a contributing factor to the enduring agrarian crisis of the late Republic.^[177][178] Large latifundia owners became wary of maintaining large concentrations of enslaved men trained in weapons or taken as adult prisoners of war.^[177][179] Roman slaveholders increasingly shifted toward breeding home-born slaves (vernae), whom they viewed as more pliable and acculturated than foreign captives.^[177][178]

The rebellion also accelerated the development of the colonatus system, under which landowners leased small plots of arable land to tenant farmers and freedmen in exchange for a portion of the harvest.^[177][178] Manumissions increased, and administrative oversight of enslaved populations shifted from an exclusively private household matter to an issue of state security.^[177][180] In 70 BC, Roman censors enrolled hundreds of thousands of Italian allies into the citizen rolls, formalizing citizenship concessions that had been delayed since the Social War; this was possibly one consequence of the uprising, as the Romans sought to improve the position of the Italians and keep them from new revolts.^[126]

Historiographical perspectives

In Roman literature, Spartacus became an archetype of terror, ranked alongside Hannibal Barca as one of the Republic's greatest existential threats.^[181][182] Roman orators used his name as a political insult: Cicero branded Catiline a gladiator and warned that his victory would surrender power to runaway slaves, while Mark Antony and Cicero traded accusations comparing young Octavian and Antony to Spartacus.^{[183][184][185][186]} Late Roman poets, including Claudian and Sidonius Apollinaris in the fifth century AD, invoked Spartacus's victories over consuls to lament Roman vulnerability.^[182] Late antique Christian writers showed little interest in him; Saint Augustine mentioned the uprising without naming Spartacus, viewing the crucified slaves as prefiguring Christian martyrdom, while Jerome referred impersonally to the gladiatorial war in Campania.^[187][188]

During the eighteenth-century Enlightenment, European thinkers reassessed the Third Servile War as a struggle against tyrannical oppression.^[189][190] Denis Diderot praised Spartacus in the Encyclopedie as an early defender of natural human rights, and Voltaire described the conflict as the only just war in history.^[189][191] In 1793, August Gottlieb Meissner published the first dedicated academic monograph examining the classical sources on the rebellion.^[192] Historian Barthold Georg Niebuhr subsequently argued that the institution of slavery was a primary cause of the collapse of the Roman Republic.^[193]

Nineteenth-century scholarship was shaped by contrasting interpretations developed by Theodor Mommsen and Karl Marx.^[194][195] Mommsen characterized the rebellion as a bandit uprising that failed due to lack of purpose and the undisciplined nature of Celtic and Germanic fighters, though he acknowledged Spartacus as an exceptional commander who was superior to his followers.^{[194][196][197]} Karl Marx wrote to Friedrich Engels in 1861 that Spartacus was the most splendid figure in ancient history, an authentic representative of the ancient proletariat.^{[197][198][199]} Sociologist Max Weber later rejected Marxist models of slave class consciousness, arguing that antique slaves were too socially differentiated to form a unified revolutionary class.^[200]

Twentieth-century historiography in the Soviet Union heavily emphasized the uprising, influenced by Joseph Stalin's 1933 declaration that the revolution of slaves overturned slaveowners and dismantled antiquity.^[201] Soviet historians such as Alexander Mishulin argued that Spartacus aimed to abolish slavery entirely, provoking Caesar's counter-revolution.^[201][202] During the Khrushchev Thaw, Sergei Utchenko discarded the concept of a slave revolution, concluding that while Spartacus led a revolutionary uprising, the objective historical conditions precluded the abolition of slavery.^[203][204] In Western scholarship, Italian historian Antonio Guarino proposed in 1979 that the conflict was primarily an agrarian revolt of rural, impoverished Italy against wealthy urban centers, a thesis echoed by Giovanni Brizzi and other modern researchers.^[205]

Cultural legacy

Spartacus has served as a symbol for revolutionary and abolitionist movements across the modern era.^{[189][198][206]} Toussaint Louverture, the leader of the Haitian Revolution, was widely celebrated as the Black Spartacus.^[206][207] Adam Weishaupt, the founder of the Bavarian Illuminati, used Spartacus as his code name in correspondence.^[208][209] In Germany, Karl Liebknecht and Rosa Luxemburg founded the Spartacus League (Spartakusbund) during World War I, which launched the Spartacist Uprising in January 1919 and became the precursor to the Communist Party of Germany.^{[210][211][212]}

The rebellion has been dramatized in numerous literary works.^{[213][214][215]} Bernard-Joseph Saurin's 1760 tragedy Spartacus established him as a noble hero on the French stage.^[189][190] In 1874, Italian novelist Raffaello Giovagnoli published the historical novel Spartaco, which Giuseppe Garibaldi celebrated in an introductory letter as an inspiration for liberation from tyranny.^[212][216] Subsequent major novels include Lewis Grassic Gibbon's Spartacus (1933), Arthur Koestler's The Gladiators (1939), which allegorized Soviet totalitarianism, and Howard Fast's bestselling Spartacus (1951), written while the author was imprisoned for political convictions and awarded the Stalin Peace Prize in 1954.^{[212][215][217][218][219]}

Cinematic and televisual adaptations have reached global audiences.^[213][220] Early silent films were produced in Italy in 1913 by Giovanni Enrico Vidali and in the Soviet Union in 1926 by Muhsin Ertugrul.^[220][221] Riccardo Freda directed the 1953 film Sins of Rome starring Massimo Girotti.^[220] In 1960, Stanley Kubrick directed the Hollywood film Spartacus, produced by and starring Kirk Douglas with a screenplay by Dalton Trumbo based on Fast's novel.^[222][223] Television productions include Robert Dornhelm's 2004 miniseries starring Goran Visnjic and the Starz television series Spartacus (2010–2013), starring Andy Whitfield and Liam McIntyre.^{[224][225][226]}

Spartacus has also inspired classical and modern music.^[214] Camille Saint-Saens composed the Spartacus Overture in 1863. Soviet-Armenian composer Aram Khachaturian composed the ballet Spartacus in 1954, premiered in Leningrad in 1956, which became a permanent fixture of the Bolshoi Ballet repertoire.^[212][227] In popular music, German progressive rock group Triumvirat released the album Spartacus in 1975, and Jeff Wayne produced Jeff Wayne's Musical Version of Spartacus in 1992.^[212]

In the Soviet Union and Eastern Europe, sports clubs and mass athletic festivals were named in his honor.^[228][229] From 1921, Spartakiads were held in Soviet Russia as sports competitions originally meant to replace the Olympic Games.^{[227][228][229]} The Spartak sports society in the USSR sponsored prominent teams, including FC Spartak Moscow, HC Spartak Moscow, and numerous clubs across Bulgaria, Slovakia, and Serbia.^[229][230] In geography and astronomy, Spartacus Peak on Livingston Island in Antarctica and asteroid 2579 Spartacus bear his name.^[231]

References

1. Shaw, Brent (2018). Spartacus and the Slave Wars: A Brief History with Documents. Boston: Bedford. p. 21. ISBN 9781319094829. It is critical to bear in mind that not one of these documents was written by a slave or a former slave... The most important written sources for any reconstruction of the Spartacus slave war are the accounts by the Roman historian Sallust, the Greek biographer Plutarch, and the Greek historian Appian. Of these three, the account by Sallust is usually deemed to be the most important, since he was closest to the events. Sallust was writing in the generation after the war. The other two writers, Plutarch and Appian, not only came from a different culture (Greek), but they also composed their accounts about two centuries after the events occurred...When reading their accounts, readers must remember that these are not eyewitness reports but much later reconstructions.
2. Мотус, 1957, с. 161. (Мотус А. О датировке начала восстания Спартака // Вестник древней истории. — 1957. — № 3. — С. 158—166.)
3. Historische Gestalten der Antike, 2013, s. 943—944. (Historische Gestalten der Antike. Rezeption in Literatur, Kunst und Musik / Peter von Möllendorff, Annette Simonis, Linda Simonis. — Stuttgart: Metzler, 2013. — 1183 с. — ISBN 978-3-476-02468-8.)
4. Teyssier 2012, p. 8-10.
5. "Conde Library: Spartacus' slave rebellion". Pymble Ladies College.
6. Флор, 1996, II, 8, 8. (Луций Анней Флор. Эпитомы // Малые римские историки. — М.: Ладомир, 1996. — С. 99—190. — ISBN 5-86218-125-3.)
7. Philippe Le Doze, « Rome et les idéologies : réflexions sur les conditions nécessaires à l’émergence des idéologies politiques », Revue historique, vol. 3, no 675,‎ 2015, p. 587-618 (lire en ligne).
8. Мотус, 1957, с. 161—166. (Мотус А. О датировке начала восстания Спартака // Вестник древней истории. — 1957. — № 3. — С. 158—166.)
9. Евтропий, 2001, VI, 7, 2. (Евтропий. Бревиарий римской истории. — СПб.: Алетейя, 2001. — 305 с. — ISBN 5-89329-345-2.)
10. Евтропий, 2001, VI, 7, 1. (Евтропий. Бревиарий римской истории. — СПб.: Алетейя, 2001. — 305 с. — ISBN 5-89329-345-2.)
11. Орозий, 2004, V, 24, 1. (Павел Орозий. История против язычников. — СПб.: Издательство Олега Абышко, 2004. — ISBN 5-7435-0214-5.)
12. Мотус, 1957, с. 158—160. (Мотус А. О датировке начала восстания Спартака // Вестник древней истории. — 1957. — № 3. — С. 158—166.)
13. Мишулин, 1936, с. 110—112. (Мишулин А. Революции рабов и падение Римской республики. — М.: Правда, 1936. — 112 с.)
14. Хёфлинг, 1992, с. 3. (Хёфлинг Г. Римляне, рабы, гладиаторы. Спартак у ворот Рима. — М.: Мысль, 1992. — 270 с. — ISBN 5-244-00596-0.)
15. Этьен, 2009, с. 57. (Этьен Р. Цезарь. — М.: Молодая гвардия, 2009. — 299 с. — (Жизнь замечательных людей). — ISBN 978-5-235-03302-3.)
16. Горончаровский, 2011, с. 46. (Горончаровский В. Спартаковская война. — СПб.: Петербургское востоковедение, 2011. — 176 с. — ISBN 978-5-85803-428-6.)
17. Егоров, 2014, с. 119. (Егоров А. Юлий Цезарь. Политическая биография. — СПб.: Нестор-История, 2014. — 548 с. — ISBN 978-5-4469-0389-4.)
18. Мотус, 1957, с. 166. (Мотус А. О датировке начала восстания Спартака // Вестник древней истории. — 1957. — № 3. — С. 158—166.)
19. Ковалёв, 2002, с. 476. (Ковалёв С. История Рима. — М.: Полигон, 2002. — 864 с. — ISBN 5-89173-171-1.)
20. Аппиан, 2002, XIII, 116. (Аппиан Александрийский. Римская история. — М.: Ладомир, 2002. — 880 с. — ISBN 5-86218-174-1.)
21. Плутарх, 1994, Красс, 8. (Плутарх. Сравнительные жизнеописания. — М.: Наука, 1994. — ISBN 5-02-011570-3. — ISBN 5-02-011568-1.)
22. Орозий, 2004, V, 24. (Павел Орозий. История против язычников. — СПб.: Издательство Олега Абышко, 2004. — ISBN 5-7435-0214-5.)
23. Афиней, 2004, VI, 272F. (Афиней. Пир мудрецов. — М.: Наука, 2004. — 656 с. — ISBN 5-02-010237-7.)
24. Никишин, 2009, с. 98—99. (Никишин В. О биографии Спартака до начала «рабской войны» // Studia historica. — 2009. — № IX. — С. 98—105.)
25. "Plutarch, Crassus 8". Archived from the original on 10 April 2020. Retrieved 26 November 2006.
26. Ziegler, 1955, s. 248—250. (Ziegler K. Die Herkunft des Spartacus // Hermes. — 1955. — № 83. — С. 248—250.)
27. Никишин, 2009, с. 99. (Никишин В. О биографии Спартака до начала «рабской войны» // Studia historica. — 2009. — № IX. — С. 98—105.)
28. Горончаровский, 2011, с. 10. (Горончаровский В. Спартаковская война. — СПб.: Петербургское востоковедение, 2011. — 176 с. — ISBN 978-5-85803-428-6.)
29. Teyssier 2012, p. 28-30.
30. John Boardman; I. E. S. Edwards, N. G. L. Hammond and E. Sollberger, eds. (1982). The Cambridge Ancient History (PDF) (2nd ed.). Cambridge University Press. doi:10.1017/CHOL9780521224963. ISBN 978-0521224963.
31. 土井 1994,pp.53-55;プルタルコス,p.19.
32. 土井 1994,pp.54-55.
33. Barry S. Strauss, The Spartacus war, стр.31, Simon and Schuster, 2009. ISBN 1-4165-3205-6
34. Velkova, 1981, s. 197. (Velkova Z. Der Name Spartacus // Spartacus : Symposium Rebus Spartaci Gestis Dedicatum 2050 A., Blagoevgrad, 20—24.IX.1977. — 1981. — С. 195—198.)
35. InStoria - La rivolta di Spartaco, su instoria.it. URL consultato il 7 agosto 2021.
36. Diodorus Siculus, Historical Library Book 12
37. Diodorus Siculus, Historical Library Book 16
38. Моммзен, 1997, с. 100—101. (Моммзен Т. История Рима. — Ростов-на-Дону: Феникс, 1997. — Т. 3. — 640 с. — ISBN 5-222-00047-8.)
39. "Tribes, Dynasts and Kingdoms of Northern Greece: History and Numismatics". Archived from the original on 27 August 2007. Retrieved 28 February 2007.
40. 土井 1994,p.53;土井 1977,pp.163-164.
41. Teyssier 2009, p. 32.
42. Schiavone 2014, p. 27-33.
43. Appian, Civil Wars 1.116 Archived 3 June 2020 at the Wayback Machine
44. Florus, Epitome of Roman History 2.8.8
45. Ziegler, 1955, s. 249. (Ziegler K. Die Herkunft des Spartacus // Hermes. — 1955. — № 83. — С. 248—250.)
46. Горончаровский, 2011, с. 14—15. (Горончаровский В. Спартаковская война. — СПб.: Петербургское востоковедение, 2011. — 176 с. — ISBN 978-5-85803-428-6.)
47. Danov, 1983, s. 12. (Danov C. Einige beachtenswerte Wesenszüge des Spartakusaufstandes und seines Anführers // Antiquitas. — 1983. — № X. — С. 9—14.)
48. Моммзен, 1997, с. 101. (Моммзен Т. История Рима. — Ростов-на-Дону: Феникс, 1997. — Т. 3. — 640 с. — ISBN 5-222-00047-8.)
49. Gabba, 1958, p. 317. (Gabba E. Commento // Appiani bellorum civilium liber primus. — 1958.)
50. Никишин, 2009, с. 102. (Никишин В. О биографии Спартака до начала «рабской войны» // Studia historica. — 2009. — № IX. — С. 98—105.)
51. Горончаровский, 2011, с. 15. (Горончаровский В. Спартаковская война. — СПб.: Петербургское востоковедение, 2011. — 176 с. — ISBN 978-5-85803-428-6.)
52. Никишин, 2009, с. 102-103. (Никишин В. О биографии Спартака до начала «рабской войны» // Studia historica. — 2009. — № IX. — С. 98—105.)
53. Тацит, 1993, Анналы, III, 73, 2. (Публий Корнелий Тацит. Анналы // Тацит. Сочинения. — СПб.: Наука, 1993. — С. 7—312. — ISBN 5-02-028170-0.)
54. Диодор Сицилийский, XXXVIII, 21. (Диодор Сицилийский. [[Историческая библиотека]] . Сайт «Симпосий». Дата обращения: 30 сентября 2017.)
55. Никишин, 2009, с. 101; 103. (Никишин В. О биографии Спартака до начала «рабской войны» // Studia historica. — 2009. — № IX. — С. 98—105.)
56. Никишин, 2009, с. 104. (Никишин В. О биографии Спартака до начала «рабской войны» // Studia historica. — 2009. — № IX. — С. 98—105.)
57. Сергеенко, 2000, с. 218. (Сергеенко М. Е. Жизнь Древнего Рима / науч. ред. А. В. Жервэ. — СПб.: Издательско-торговый дом «Летний Сад»; Журнал «Нева», 2000. — 368 с. — ISBN 5-89740-026-1.)
58. Plutarco, Crasso.
59. プルタルコス,p.18.
60. Горончаровский, 2011, с. 45. (Горончаровский В. Спартаковская война. — СПб.: Петербургское востоковедение, 2011. — 176 с. — ISBN 978-5-85803-428-6.)
61. Strauss 2009, p. 11 (Strauss, Barry (2009). The Spartacus War. Simon & Schuster. ISBN 978-1-4165-3205-7.)
62. Salles 1990, p. 8-10.
63. Appien, Guerres civiles, I, 116.
64. Горончаровский, 2011, с. 38—42. (Горончаровский В. Спартаковская война. — СПб.: Петербургское востоковедение, 2011. — 176 с. — ISBN 978-5-85803-428-6.)
65. Strauss 2009, p. 13. (Strauss, Barry (2009). The Spartacus War. Simon & Schuster. ISBN 978-1-4165-3205-7.)
66. ウィズダム 2002,p.128.
67. Salles 1990, p. 10.
68. William Smith, Dictionary of Greek and Roman Antiquities, «Gladiatores» (anglès).
69. Горончаровский, 2011, с. 45—46. (Горончаровский В. Спартаковская война. — СПб.: Петербургское востоковедение, 2011. — 176 с. — ISBN 978-5-85803-428-6.)
70. Хёфлинг, 1992, с. 3—4. (Хёфлинг Г. Римляне, рабы, гладиаторы. Спартак у ворот Рима. — М.: Мысль, 1992. — 270 с. — ISBN 5-244-00596-0.)
71. However, according to Cicero (Ad Atticum VI, ii, 8) at the beginning his followers were much less than 50.
72. Флор, 1996, II, 8, 3. (Луций Анней Флор. Эпитомы // Малые римские историки. — М.: Ладомир, 1996. — С. 99—190. — ISBN 5-86218-125-3.)
73. Саллюстий, III, 90. (Гай Саллюстий Крисп. История . Дата обращения: 26 сентября 2017.)
74. Тит Ливий, 1994, Периохи, 95. (Тит Ливий. История Рима от основания города. — М.: Наука, 1994. — Т. 3. — 768 с. — ISBN 5-02-008995-8.)
75. Фронтин, Стратагемы, V, 21. (Секст Юлий Фронтин. Военные хитрости . Сайт «ХLegio». Дата обращения: 22 сентября 2017.)
76. È opportuno ricordare che, in epoca romana, fino alla famosa eruzione del 79 d.C. che distrusse Pompei ed Ercolano non si sapeva che il Vesuvio fosse un vulcano, poiché l'ultima eruzione risaliva a diversi secoli prima e le pendici della montagna erano ricoperte di boschi.
77. Πλούταρχος, Βίοι Παράλληλοι, «Κράσος» 9.1-2.
78. Горончаровский, 2011, с. 47—48. (Горончаровский В. Спартаковская война. — СПб.: Петербургское востоковедение, 2011. — 176 с. — ISBN 978-5-85803-428-6.)
79. Salles 1990, p. 13-16.
80. Горончаровский, 2011, с. 48. (Горончаровский В. Спартаковская война. — СПб.: Петербургское востоковедение, 2011. — 176 с. — ISBN 978-5-85803-428-6.)
81. Мишулин, 1950, с. 71. (Мишулин А. Спартак. — М.: Учпедгиз, 1950. — 146 с.)
82. Plutarch, Crassus, 9:1–3 Archived 17 November 2020 at the Wayback Machine; Frontinus, Stratagems, Book I, 5:20–22; Appian, Civil Wars, 1:116 Archived 3 June 2020 at the Wayback Machine; Broughton, Magistrates of the Roman Republic, p. 109.
83. Хёфлинг, 1992, с. 199—200. (Хёфлинг Г. Римляне, рабы, гладиаторы. Спартак у ворот Рима. — М.: Мысль, 1992. — 270 с. — ISBN 5-244-00596-0.)
84. «Biography of Spartacus, an Enslaved Man Who Led a Revolt». ThoughtCo (στα Αγγλικά). Αρχειοθετήθηκε από το πρωτότυπο στις 25 Σεπτεμβρίου 2008. Ανακτήθηκε στις 23 Σεπτεμβρίου 2008.
85. Плутарх, 1994, Красс, 9. (Плутарх. Сравнительные жизнеописания. — М.: Наука, 1994. — ISBN 5-02-011570-3. — ISBN 5-02-011568-1.)
86. Флор, 1996, II, 8, 4. (Луций Анней Флор. Эпитомы // Малые римские историки. — М.: Ладомир, 1996. — С. 99—190. — ISBN 5-86218-125-3.)
87. Горончаровский, 2011, с. 50—52. (Горончаровский В. Спартаковская война. — СПб.: Петербургское востоковедение, 2011. — 176 с. — ISBN 978-5-85803-428-6.)
88. Florus, Histoire romaine, III, 21.
89. Plutarch, Crassus, 9:3 Archived 10 April 2020 at the Wayback Machine; Appian, Civil War, 1:116 Archived 3 June 2020 at the Wayback Machine.
90. Αππιανός, Εμφυλίων Α΄ 116
91. Горончаровский, 2011, с. 68—75. (Горончаровский В. Спартаковская война. — СПб.: Петербургское востоковедение, 2011. — 176 с. — ISBN 978-5-85803-428-6.)
92. Хёфлинг, 1992, с. 128—130. (Хёфлинг Г. Римляне, рабы, гладиаторы. Спартак у ворот Рима. — М.: Мысль, 1992. — 270 с. — ISBN 5-244-00596-0.)
93. Περιοδικό Ιστορία Εικονογραφημένη, τχ. 33, σελ. 61.
94. Горончаровский, 2011, с. 73. (Горончаровский В. Спартаковская война. — СПб.: Петербургское востоковедение, 2011. — 176 с. — ISBN 978-5-85803-428-6.)
95. Саллюстий, История, III, 96. (Гай Саллюстий Крисп. История . Дата обращения: 26 сентября 2017.)
96. Фронтин, Стратагемы, VII, 6. (Секст Юлий Фронтин. Военные хитрости . Сайт «ХLegio». Дата обращения: 22 сентября 2017.)
97. Хёфлинг, 1992, с. 129. (Хёфлинг Г. Римляне, рабы, гладиаторы. Спартак у ворот Рима. — М.: Мысль, 1992. — 270 с. — ISBN 5-244-00596-0.)
98. Горончаровский, 2011, с. 77. (Горончаровский В. Спартаковская война. — СПб.: Петербургское востоковедение, 2011. — 176 с. — ISBN 978-5-85803-428-6.)
99. Флор, 1996, II, 8, 7. (Луций Анней Флор. Эпитомы // Малые римские историки. — М.: Ладомир, 1996. — С. 99—190. — ISBN 5-86218-125-3.)
100. Горончаровский, 2011, с. 78—81. (Горончаровский В. Спартаковская война. — СПб.: Петербургское востоковедение, 2011. — 176 с. — ISBN 978-5-85803-428-6.)
101. Горончаровский, 2011, с. 84—86. (Горончаровский В. Спартаковская война. — СПб.: Петербургское востоковедение, 2011. — 176 с. — ISBN 978-5-85803-428-6.)
102. Florus, Epitome, 2.8.
103. Саллюстий, История, III, 98. (Гай Саллюстий Крисп. История . Дата обращения: 26 сентября 2017.)
104. Salluste, Histoires, CCCI.
105. Орозий, 2004, V, 24, 3. (Павел Орозий. История против язычников. — СПб.: Издательство Олега Абышко, 2004. — ISBN 5-7435-0214-5.)
106. Горончаровский, 2011, с. 82—83. (Горончаровский В. Спартаковская война. — СПб.: Петербургское востоковедение, 2011. — 176 с. — ISBN 978-5-85803-428-6.)
107. Орозий, 2004, V, 24, 2. (Павел Орозий. История против язычников. — СПб.: Издательство Олега Абышко, 2004. — ISBN 5-7435-0214-5.)
108. Горончаровский, 2011, с. 86—89. (Горончаровский В. Спартаковская война. — СПб.: Петербургское востоковедение, 2011. — 176 с. — ISBN 978-5-85803-428-6.)
109. Плутарх, 1994, Катон, 8. (Плутарх. Сравнительные жизнеописания. — М.: Наука, 1994. — ISBN 5-02-011570-3. — ISBN 5-02-011568-1.)
110. Appian, Civil Wars, 1:117 Archived 3 June 2020 at the Wayback Machine; Plutarch, Crassus 9:7 Archived 10 April 2020 at the Wayback Machine; Livy, Periochae 96 Archived 19 July 2017 at the Wayback Machine.
111. Тит Ливий, 1994, Периохи, 96. (Тит Ливий. История Рима от основания города. — М.: Наука, 1994. — Т. 3. — 768 с. — ISBN 5-02-008995-8.)
112. Аппиан, 2002, XIII, 117. (Аппиан Александрийский. Римская история. — М.: Ладомир, 2002. — 880 с. — ISBN 5-86218-174-1.)
113. Горончаровский, 2011, с. 90. (Горончаровский В. Спартаковская война. — СПб.: Петербургское востоковедение, 2011. — 176 с. — ISBN 978-5-85803-428-6.)
114. Мишулин, 1950, с. 73. (Мишулин А. Спартак. — М.: Учпедгиз, 1950. — 146 с.)
115. Хёфлинг, 1992, с. 201-204. (Хёфлинг Г. Римляне, рабы, гладиаторы. Спартак у ворот Рима. — М.: Мысль, 1992. — 270 с. — ISBN 5-244-00596-0.)
116. Горончаровский, 2011, с. 92—95. (Горончаровский В. Спартаковская война. — СПб.: Петербургское востоковедение, 2011. — 176 с. — ISBN 978-5-85803-428-6.)
117. Αππιανός, Εμφυλίων Α΄,117
118. Ρίγκομπερτ Γκίντερ, σελ 21: «Σύμφωνα με τη ρωμαϊκή αριστοκρατική αντίληψη ένας πόλεμος ενάντια σε εξεγερμένους δούλους θεωρούνταν, βέβαια, απαραίτητος, όχι όμως και αξιοπρεπής. Ο νικητής δεν απολάμβανε στη Ρώμη τον λεγόμενο μεγάλο θρίαμβο, αλλά τη λιγότερο πανηγυρική πεζή είσοδο, τη λεγόμενη ovatio.»
119. 土井 1973,p.123
120. Floro, ii.8; Bradley, p. 121; Smith, p. 574.
121. Горончаровский, 2011, с. 96—98. (Горончаровский В. Спартаковская война. — СПб.: Петербургское востоковедение, 2011. — 176 с. — ISBN 978-5-85803-428-6.)
122. Teyssier 2012, p. 195.
123. Горончаровский, 2011, с. 98. (Горончаровский В. Спартаковская война. — СПб.: Петербургское востоковедение, 2011. — 176 с. — ISBN 978-5-85803-428-6.)
124. «Spartacus (2)». web.archive.org. Αρχειοθετήθηκε από το πρωτότυπο στις 14 Σεπτεμβρίου 2008.
125. Plutarch, Crassus 9,5.
126. Егоров, 2014, с. 120. (Егоров А. Юлий Цезарь. Политическая биография. — СПб.: Нестор-История, 2014. — 548 с. — ISBN 978-5-4469-0389-4.)
127. Коптев. (Коптев А. В. Несколько замечаний о восстании Спартака . Сайт «История Древнего Рима» (2001). Дата обращения: 30 сентября 2017.)
128. Горончаровский, 2011, с. 97; 100—101. (Горончаровский В. Спартаковская война. — СПб.: Петербургское востоковедение, 2011. — 176 с. — ISBN 978-5-85803-428-6.)
129. Горончаровский, 2011, с. 101—102. (Горончаровский В. Спартаковская война. — СПб.: Петербургское востоковедение, 2011. — 176 с. — ISBN 978-5-85803-428-6.)
130. Appiano, I, 117.
131. Орозий, 2004, V, 24, 5. (Павел Орозий. История против язычников. — СПб.: Издательство Олега Абышко, 2004. — ISBN 5-7435-0214-5.)
132. Любимова, 2013, с. 74. (Любимова О. Письмо Красса о вызове Помпея и М. Лукулла против Спартака: время и обстоятельства написания // Вестник гуманитарного университета. — 2013. — № 2. — С. 73—84.)
133. Appian, Civil Wars, 1:118 Archived 3 June 2020 at the Wayback Machine.
134. Smith, William (1870). A Dictionary of Greek and Roman Antiquities, "Exercitus", p. 494 "Dictionary of Greek and Roman Antiquities, page 494". Archived from the original on 6 October 2012. Retrieved 4 January 2010..
135. Горончаровский, 2011, с. 109. (Горончаровский В. Спартаковская война. — СПб.: Петербургское востоковедение, 2011. — 176 с. — ISBN 978-5-85803-428-6.)
136. Spartacus, 1929, s. 1533—1534. (Münzer F. Spartacus // Paulys Realencyclopädie der classischen Altertumswissenschaft. — Stuttgart: Metzler, 1929. — Bd. II, 6. — S. 1528—1536.)
137. Горончаровский, 2011, с. 111—113. (Горончаровский В. Спартаковская война. — СПб.: Петербургское востоковедение, 2011. — 176 с. — ISBN 978-5-85803-428-6.)
138. Plutarch, Crassus, 10:1–3 Archived 10 April 2020 at the Wayback Machine.
139. Appian, Bürgerkriege 1,119.
140. Spartacus, 1929, s. 1534. (Münzer F. Spartacus // Paulys Realencyclopädie der classischen Altertumswissenschaft. — Stuttgart: Metzler, 1929. — Bd. II, 6. — S. 1528—1536.)
141. Плутарх, 1994, Красс, 10. (Плутарх. Сравнительные жизнеописания. — М.: Наука, 1994. — ISBN 5-02-011570-3. — ISBN 5-02-011568-1.)
142. Горончаровский, 2011, с. 115; 119—121. (Горончаровский В. Спартаковская война. — СПб.: Петербургское востоковедение, 2011. — 176 с. — ISBN 978-5-85803-428-6.)
143. Горончаровский, 2011, с. 114—119. (Горончаровский В. Спартаковская война. — СПб.: Петербургское востоковедение, 2011. — 176 с. — ISBN 978-5-85803-428-6.)
144. Florus, Epitome, 2.8; Cicero, Orations, "For Quintius, Sextus Roscius...", 5.2 Archived 27 March 2008 at the Wayback Machine
145. ლომოური ნ., სპარტაკი, გამოჩენილ ადამიანთა ცხოვრება, 9, თბ., 1963, გვ., 68-69
146. Цицерон, 1993, Против Верреса, V, 2, 5. (Марк Туллий Цицерон. Речи. — М.: Наука, 1993. — 848 с. — ISBN 5-02-011168-6.)
147. Plutarco, Crasso, x.4-5.
148. Plutarque, Crassus, 11.
149. Plutarco, Craso, 10:4-5.
150. Горончаровский, 2011, с. 123—125. (Горончаровский В. Спартаковская война. — СПб.: Петербургское востоковедение, 2011. — 176 с. — ISBN 978-5-85803-428-6.)
151. Аппиан, 2002, XIII, 119. (Аппиан Александрийский. Римская история. — М.: Ладомир, 2002. — 880 с. — ISBN 5-86218-174-1.)
152. Αππιανός, Εμφυλίων Α΄ 119
153. Аппиан, 2002, XIII, 120. (Аппиан Александрийский. Римская история. — М.: Ладомир, 2002. — 880 с. — ISBN 5-86218-174-1.)
154. Горончаровский, 2011, с. 126—131. (Горончаровский В. Спартаковская война. — СПб.: Петербургское востоковедение, 2011. — 176 с. — ISBN 978-5-85803-428-6.)
155. Contrast Plutarch, Crassus, 11:2 Archived 10 April 2020 at the Wayback Machine with Appian, Civil Wars, 1:119 Archived 3 June 2020 at the Wayback Machine.
156. Любимова, 2013, с. 75—83. (Любимова О. Письмо Красса о вызове Помпея и М. Лукулла против Спартака: время и обстоятельства написания // Вестник гуманитарного университета. — 2013. — № 2. — С. 73—84.)
157. Strachan-Davidson über Appian. 1,120; Appian, Bürgerkriege 1,120; Plutarch, Crassus 11,2.
158. Плутарх, 1994, Красс, 11. (Плутарх. Сравнительные жизнеописания. — М.: Наука, 1994. — ISBN 5-02-011570-3. — ISBN 5-02-011568-1.)
159. Тит Ливий, 1994, Периохи, 97. (Тит Ливий. История Рима от основания города. — М.: Наука, 1994. — Т. 3. — 768 с. — ISBN 5-02-008995-8.)
160. ლომოური ნ., სპარტაკი, გამოჩენილ ადამიანთა ცხოვრება, 9, თბ., 1963, გვ., 71-72
161. Фронтин. О военных хитростях. II. 4. 7
162. Οι Μεγάλοι Επαναστάτες, σελ. 15.
163. Plutarch, Crassus, 11:5 Archived 10 April 2020 at the Wayback Machine;.
164. Πλούταρχος, Βίοι Παράλληλοι, «Κράσος» 11.7-8.
165. Spartacus, 1929, s. 1535. (Münzer F. Spartacus // Paulys Realencyclopädie der classischen Altertumswissenschaft. — Stuttgart: Metzler, 1929. — Bd. II, 6. — S. 1528—1536.)
166. Веллей Патеркул, 1996, II, 30, 6. (Гай Веллей Патеркул. Римская история // Малые римские историки. — М.: Ладомир, 1996. — С. 11—98. — ISBN 5-86218-125-3.)
167. Горончаровский, 2011, с. 135—136. (Горончаровский В. Спартаковская война. — СПб.: Петербургское востоковедение, 2011. — 176 с. — ISBN 978-5-85803-428-6.)
168. Горончаровский, 2011, с. 138—140. (Горончаровский В. Спартаковская война. — СПб.: Петербургское востоковедение, 2011. — 176 с. — ISBN 978-5-85803-428-6.)
169. Горончаровский, 2011, с. 140—141. (Горончаровский В. Спартаковская война. — СПб.: Петербургское востоковедение, 2011. — 176 с. — ISBN 978-5-85803-428-6.)
170. Плутарх, 1994, Периохи, 97. (Плутарх. Сравнительные жизнеописания. — М.: Наука, 1994. — ISBN 5-02-011570-3. — ISBN 5-02-011568-1.)
171. Горончаровский, 2011, с. 141. (Горончаровский В. Спартаковская война. — СПб.: Петербургское востоковедение, 2011. — 176 с. — ISBN 978-5-85803-428-6.)
172. Philip Matyszak: The Enemies of Rome. From Hannibal to Attila the Hun. Thames & Hudson, London 2004 S. 133; Plutarch, Pompeius 21,2; Crassus 11,7.
173. Плиний Старший, XV, 29, 125. (Плиний Старший. [[Естественная история (Плиний)|Естественная история]] . Дата обращения: 16 сентября 2017.)
174. Авл Геллий, 2007, V, 6, 23. (Авл Геллий. Аттические ночи. Книги 1 — 10. — СПб.: Издательский центр «Гуманитарная академия», 2007. — 480 с. — ISBN 978-5-93762-027-9.)
175. Цицерон, 1993, Против Верреса, V, 15, 38—39; 16, 40. (Марк Туллий Цицерон. Речи. — М.: Наука, 1993. — 848 с. — ISBN 5-02-011168-6.)
176. Светоний, 1999, Божественный Август, 3, 1. (Гай Светоний Транквилл. Жизнь двенадцати цезарей // Светоний. Властелины Рима. — М.: Ладомир, 1999. — С. 12—281. — ISBN 5-86218-365-5.)
177. Ковалёв, 2002, с. 480—481. (Ковалёв С. История Рима. — М.: Полигон, 2002. — 864 с. — ISBN 5-89173-171-1.)
178. URL de la referencia: https://www.ne.se/uppslagsverk/encyklopedi/l%C3%A5ng/spartacus.
179. Ιστορία του Ελληνικού Έθνους, Τόμος ΣΤ' (Ελληνισμός και Ρώμη), Εκδοτική Αθηνών, Αθήνα 1979 σελ. 87
180. Утченко, 1965, с. 148. (Утченко С. Кризис и падение Римской республики. — М.: Мысль, 1965. — 288 с.)
181. Spartacus, 1929, s. 1536. (Münzer F. Spartacus // Paulys Realencyclopädie der classischen Altertumswissenschaft. — Stuttgart: Metzler, 1929. — Bd. II, 6. — S. 1528—1536.)
182. Горончаровский, 2011, с. 153. (Горончаровский В. Спартаковская война. — СПб.: Петербургское востоковедение, 2011. — 176 с. — ISBN 978-5-85803-428-6.)
183. Цицерон, 1993, Против Катилины, I, 12. (Марк Туллий Цицерон. Речи. — М.: Наука, 1993. — 848 с. — ISBN 5-02-011168-6.)
184. Цицерон, 1993, Против Катилины, II, 19. (Марк Туллий Цицерон. Речи. — М.: Наука, 1993. — 848 с. — ISBN 5-02-011168-6.)
185. Цицерон, 1993, Филиппики, III, 21. (Марк Туллий Цицерон. Речи. — М.: Наука, 1993. — 848 с. — ISBN 5-02-011168-6.)
186. Цицерон, 1993, Филиппики, IV, 15; XIII, 22. (Марк Туллий Цицерон. Речи. — М.: Наука, 1993. — 848 с. — ISBN 5-02-011168-6.)
187. Historische Gestalten der Antike, 2013, s. 944. (Historische Gestalten der Antike. Rezeption in Literatur, Kunst und Musik / Peter von Möllendorff, Annette Simonis, Linda Simonis. — Stuttgart: Metzler, 2013. — 1183 с. — ISBN 978-3-476-02468-8.)
188. Рыжов. Кем был Спартак (недоступная ссылка)
189. Historische Gestalten der Antike, 2013, s. 944-945. (Historische Gestalten der Antike. Rezeption in Literatur, Kunst und Musik / Peter von Möllendorff, Annette Simonis, Linda Simonis. — Stuttgart: Metzler, 2013. — 1183 с. — ISBN 978-3-476-02468-8.)
190. Spartacus, dans Répertoire général du théâtre français…. Théâtre du second ordre. Tragédies, tome V, H. Nicolle, Paris, 1818, sur Gallica.
191. Voltaire (1821). "Oeuvres 53, vol. 9, Correspondance générale, 461-3, no. 283".
192. Rubinsohn, 1993, s. 33—34. (Rubinsohn W. Die grossen Sklavenaufstände der Antike. — Darmstadt: Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft, 1993. — 242 с. — ISBN 3-534-08807-7.)
193. Rubinsohn, 1993, s. 39—40. (Rubinsohn W. Die grossen Sklavenaufstände der Antike. — Darmstadt: Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft, 1993. — 242 с. — ISBN 3-534-08807-7.)
194. Rubinsohn, 1993, s. 42—44. (Rubinsohn W. Die grossen Sklavenaufstände der Antike. — Darmstadt: Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft, 1993. — 242 с. — ISBN 3-534-08807-7.)
195. Rubinsohn, 1993, s. 44. (Rubinsohn W. Die grossen Sklavenaufstände der Antike. — Darmstadt: Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft, 1993. — 242 с. — ISBN 3-534-08807-7.)
196. Моммзен, 1997, с. 102—105. (Моммзен Т. История Рима. — Ростов-на-Дону: Феникс, 1997. — Т. 3. — 640 с. — ISBN 5-222-00047-8.)
197. Historische Gestalten der Antike, 2013, s. 946. (Historische Gestalten der Antike. Rezeption in Literatur, Kunst und Musik / Peter von Möllendorff, Annette Simonis, Linda Simonis. — Stuttgart: Metzler, 2013. — 1183 с. — ISBN 978-3-476-02468-8.)
198. de Ste. Croix, G. E. M. (1989). The Class Struggle in the Ancient Greek World. Ithaca, N.Y.: Cornell University Press. p. 25]. ISBN 978-0801495977.
199. Wilfried Nippel, « Marx, Weber et l'esclavage », Anabases, 2, 2005, § 19 [lire en ligne]
200. Rubinsohn, 1993, s. 51—54. (Rubinsohn W. Die grossen Sklavenaufstände der Antike. — Darmstadt: Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft, 1993. — 242 с. — ISBN 3-534-08807-7.)
201. Горончаровский, 2011, с. 6—7. (Горончаровский В. Спартаковская война. — СПб.: Петербургское востоковедение, 2011. — 176 с. — ISBN 978-5-85803-428-6.)
202. Утченко, 1965, с. 144—145. (Утченко С. Кризис и падение Римской республики. — М.: Мысль, 1965. — 288 с.)
203. Утченко, 1965, с. 30—31. (Утченко С. Кризис и падение Римской республики. — М.: Мысль, 1965. — 288 с.)
204. Утченко, 1965, с. 147—148. (Утченко С. Кризис и падение Римской республики. — М.: Мысль, 1965. — 288 с.)
205. Rubinsohn, 1993, s. 96—97. (Rubinsohn W. Die grossen Sklavenaufstände der Antike. — Darmstadt: Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft, 1993. — 242 с. — ISBN 3-534-08807-7.)
206. Thomson, Ian (31 January 2004). "The black Spartacus". The Guardian. Patrick Leigh Fermor hailed L'Ouverture as the "black Spartacus" after the slave who challenged Rome...
207. William Wilberforce, Lettre à Monsieur le Prince de Talleyrand, 1814.
208. Douglas Reed (1978). The controversy of Zion. Dolphin Press. p. 139. ISBN 9780620041331.
209. Historische Gestalten der Antike, 2013, s. 945—946. (Historische Gestalten der Antike. Rezeption in Literatur, Kunst und Musik / Peter von Möllendorff, Annette Simonis, Linda Simonis. — Stuttgart: Metzler, 2013. — 1183 с. — ISBN 978-3-476-02468-8.)
210. Diken, Bulent (2012). Revolt, Revolution, Critique: The Paradox of Society. Routledge. p. 61. ISBN 978-1134005642. ...like the 'black Spartacus' Toussaint–Louverture, the leader of the insurgent black slaves who escaped from plantations and defeated the Napoleonic forces in Haiti in 1796–1804, or like the 'Spartacist' leaders of the communist revolt in Germany in 1919.
211. Fowkes, Ben (2014). The German Left and the Weimar Republic: A Selection of Documents. Brill. p. 71. ISBN 978-9004271081.
212. Historische Gestalten der Antike, 2013, s. 947. (Historische Gestalten der Antike. Rezeption in Literatur, Kunst und Musik / Peter von Möllendorff, Annette Simonis, Linda Simonis. — Stuttgart: Metzler, 2013. — 1183 с. — ISBN 978-3-476-02468-8.)
213. Historian Barry Strauss on His New Book The Spartacus War (Interview). Simon & Schuster. 2009. Archived from the original on 30 October 2021.
214. Rubinsohn, 1993, s. 26—27. (Rubinsohn W. Die grossen Sklavenaufstände der Antike. — Darmstadt: Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft, 1993. — 242 с. — ISBN 3-534-08807-7.)
215. Salles 1990, p. 175-178.
216. Оскоцкий, 1989, прим., с. 558. (Оскоцкий В. Уроки мастера. Творческий путь Василия Яна (В. Г. Янчевецкого) // Ян В. Собрание сочинений. — 1989. — Т. 1. — С. 5—40.)
217. Teyssier 2012, p. 139-140.
218. Hughes, 2013, p. 66. (Hughes D. The Complete Kubrick. — Random House, 2013. — P. 70. — 320 p. — ISBN 978-1-4481-3321-5.)
219. Richards, 2008, p. 84. (Richards J. Hollywood’s Ancient Worlds. — A&C Black, 2008. — P. 72. — 227 p. — ISBN 978-1-84725-007-0.)
220. Historische Gestalten der Antike, 2013, s. 948. (Historische Gestalten der Antike. Rezeption in Literatur, Kunst und Musik / Peter von Möllendorff, Annette Simonis, Linda Simonis. — Stuttgart: Metzler, 2013. — 1183 с. — ISBN 978-3-476-02468-8.)
221. Giovanni Enrico Vidali, Cristina Ruspoli, Enrico Bracci et Maria Gandini, Spartacus, 11 mai 1914 (lire en ligne)
222. Historische Gestalten der Antike, 2013, s. 947—948. (Historische Gestalten der Antike. Rezeption in Literatur, Kunst und Musik / Peter von Möllendorff, Annette Simonis, Linda Simonis. — Stuttgart: Metzler, 2013. — 1183 с. — ISBN 978-3-476-02468-8.)
223. Elaine Després, « Spartacus de Howard Fast », Spirale : arts - lettres - sciences humaines, no 259,‎ 2017, p. 84-86 (ISSN 0225-9044 et 1923-3213, lire en ligne, consulté le 28 décembre 2023)
224. "Spartacus". Tvblog.ugo.com – Comic-Con 2009. 29 June 2009. Retrieved 24 February 2013.
225. "AUSXIP Spartacus: Blood and Sand TV Show Lucy Lawless Sam Raimi & Rob Tapert". Spartacus.ausxip.com. Archived from the original on 7 July 2011. Retrieved 24 February 2013.
226. Historische Gestalten der Antike, 2013, s. 949. (Historische Gestalten der Antike. Rezeption in Literatur, Kunst und Musik / Peter von Möllendorff, Annette Simonis, Linda Simonis. — Stuttgart: Metzler, 2013. — 1183 с. — ISBN 978-3-476-02468-8.)
227. Salles 1990, p. 173-175.
228. Great Soviet Encyclopedia, 3rd edition, volume 24 (part 1), p. 286, Moscow, Sovetskaya Entsiklopediya publisher, 1976.
229. РИА Новости. Спортивное общество «Спартак»: история и традиции . Дата обращения: 22 ноября 2017. Архивировано 1 декабря 2017 года.
230. spartacus-1928-egyesulet . Дата обращения: 22 ноября 2017. Архивировано 18 ноября 2017 года.
231. Lutz D. Schmadel: Dictionary of Minor Planet Names. Fifth Revised and Enlarged Edition. Hrsg.: Lutz D. Schmadel. 5. Auflage. Springer Verlag, Berlin, Heidelberg 2003, ISBN 3-540-29925-4, S. 186, doi:10.1007/978-3-540-29925-7_2580 (englisch, 992 S., Originaltitel: Dictionary of Minor Planet Names. Erstausgabe: Springer Verlag, Berlin, Heidelberg 1992): “1977 PA2. Discovered 1977 Aug. 14 by N. S. Chernykh at Nauchnyj.”